Showing posts with label h-1b visa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label h-1b visa. Show all posts

Friday, September 13, 2013

STEM Crisis Myth


Three points of interest in this post.

A very good write-up on IEEE Spectrum, I hope they don’t mind that I’m using their image to encourage you to read their article.

The STEM Crisis Is a Myth

By Robert N. Charette
Posted 30 Aug 2013 | 19:28 GMT

 

“A Matter of Supply vs. Demand: Every year U.S. schools grant more STEM degrees than there are available jobs. When you factor in H-1B visa holders, existing STEM degree holders, and the like, it’s hard to make a case that there’s a STEM labor shortage.”

http://spectrum.ieee.org/at-work/education/the-stem-crisis-is-a-myth


09STEMeducation-1377102567732

 

Friday, July 26, 2013

Computer Occupations & H-1B Report 2012

135,966 H-1B initial employment approvals in FY 2012
  • In 2012, the H-1B cap of 85,000 was exceeded by 53,446. 
  • 83,444(61.4%) of 135,966 initial employment approvals, in known occupations, went to Computer-related occupations
  • Another 924 employment approvals went to Occupations unknown for a total of  136,890 employment approvals. 

Findings:

At the core of the temporary immigration problem is the static USCIS definition of the Specialty Occupation.  With a static definition of occupations that are open to temporary immigration, we can be assured that work authorizations will be wasted in occupations where they are unneeded, while industries having a genuine need will clamor for higher immigration rates .  Moreover, the temporary immigration programs are completely insensitive to occupational unemployment rates and current degree production.  Adding workforce capacity to occupations where employment levels are declining is –- flat stupid. 
USCIS still reports to Congress using the out of print Dictionary of Occupational Titles (DOT), there is no way to crosswalk DOT occupational titles to the Standard Occupational Classification (SOC) titles because many titles did not exist at the DOT last printing in 1991. The Bureau of Labor Statistics abandoned the DOT in 1998.

The US now has the capability to determine if individual occupational levels are growing,  if growth in an occupation is stagnant or declining it would be a very trivial process to ‘close’ the occupation to temporary immigration, thus freeing up visas for occupations that are experiencing growth. 

The one year (occupation specific) temporary immigration hiatus would reduce unemployment costs, student loan defaults and home loan foreclosures because it would provide a one year period where employers would be motivated to hire from the unemployment roles if they wish to participate in the early stages of recovery from economic recession(s).

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

STEM – Don’t Let This Happen to Your Job

 

The H-1B (High skill foreign labor) debate centers around the “Computer-related occupations” employment classification.  Computer-related occupations have borne the brunt of High Skill immigration policy,  Computer-related occupations is just 2.57% of the nation’s employment, but averages 46% of all new H-1B visas and 50% of all H-1B renewals.

image

(Table 1)

image

(Table 2)

The remaining H-1B visas are distributed among seventeen occupational groups when including, “Occupation Unknown”.  In addition to the H-1B visa, we have the L-1 Intracompany visa, which is nearly identical to the H-1B.  The table below uses the Computer-related occupation percentages from Table 1 (H-1B initial approvals), to estimate population of Computer-related (C&IS) L-1 visas.

image

(Table 3)

Temporary work visas are only part of the story, we need to examine the “Bright Outlook” occupations that the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) are always pushing in Employment Projections.  The following table uses BLS Occupational Employment Statistics to determine employment level growth in Computer-related occupations. 

The “USA Jobs Remaining” column is the employment growth/loss with employment granted to temporary immigrants subtracted.

image

(Table 4)

Of course, H-1B and L-1 visas authorize employment for 3 years. We need to evaluate  the “USA Jobs Remaining” data in 3 year periods. Also note that temporary immigrant data for 2011 is still not published – so the statistic (table below) gets a “free” 117,500 jobs in 2011.

image

(Table 5)

The “USA Jobs Remaining” entries in Table 5 are a simple aggregate of the corresponding entries in the “USA Jobs Remaining” column in Table 4.  Recall that the 2011 temporary immigration data is unavailable, the  2009-11 statistic will only get worse.

Finally, we need to consider the Computer-related (C&IS) degrees conferred to citizens and permanent residents. Of course, the terms of the H-1B and L-1 visa is that there must be a job waiting upon arrival, so our students take a “back-seat” to the temporary immigrants.

image

(Table 6)

Some of the citizen and permanent resident students in Table 6 may already be employed, or may be in school full time in progress to a higher degree.  However, when they enter the workforce, they will be competing for employment with foreign students who enjoy a 29 month,  Social Security exempt while under a student visa, intern status on OPT.  (Qualified Foreign Students)

We’ve done a good job of warning American students to stay away from Computer Science majors, In the light of the USCIS announcing more eligible majors for the OPT classification, I assume the immigration lawyers are looking for other STEM occupations to victimize.

Source:

2011 OES Employment level data can be found at  National Cross-Industry 

OES Employment level data (National Cross Industry) for 1999-2010 Here

H-1B Characteristics Reports (2004 through 2010) can be found Here

L-1 visa data can be found Here (Excel)

The 1999 through 2003 H-1B Characteristics Reports appear to be unavailable online, data was taken from archive copies.

Educational data was downloaded from NSF resources before a change to the web interface. I do not know if it is still possible to query the data by residency status.

Monday, March 5, 2012

Incredible Elasticity in US Science and Engineering Labor Force

In 2010, the Unemployment level for the Science and Engineering Labor force was 426,215.  The average Science and Engineering Labor Force growth was 26,627 yearly (2005 to 2010).  During the same period, the Foreign Born, Science & Engineering Labor force grew by an average of 31,245 per year.

In terms of California Unemployment Benefit levels ($450.00 wk), the preference for foreign professionals costs the various State and Federal Unemployment Agencies $731,133,000.00 per 52 week period. 

See the US S&E heat map from the Population Reference Bureau (Link)

Excel MSA Employment Charts used in this presentation with other Metro Areas available for download. (File > Download)

The American Community Survey(Census ACS) provides data on the Science and Engineering (S&E) Labor Force statics.  The Unemployment level data include the foreign and native born.  It is important to remember that the “Labor Force” consists of the Employed” plus the “Unemployed” when evaluating the information to follow.

I’ve created some charts that detail the characteristics of the S&E employment picture in the various Metropolitan Statistical Areas (MSA).  The first Chart is the Dallas/Fort Worth MSA, where Jennifer Wedel’s husband has had problem finding Semiconductor Engineering work for the last three years.

If you are not familiar with the Wedel family, you can watch her conversation with President Obama here.

 

 

Dallas-Fort Worth-Arlington, TX Metropolitan Statistical Area

image

At first glance we see an S&E Unemployment rate that is fairly high for the Brightest and Best, but we also see a 4.1% increase in the Foreign born in the S&E Labor force for the Dallas Fort Worth MSA. 

The following chart shows that from 2008 to 2010, over 12,000 Native born S&E professionals lost employment, while more than 8,000 Foreign born professionals gained employment (2007 to 2010).

 image

Had these 8,000 jobs stayed with the Native born, the Unemployment Insurance liability for the Dallas Fort Worth MSA would have been for 4,000 professionals instead of 12,000 professionals.  Unemployment Insurance (in California) maximum is $450.00 per week, over the course of a year, benefits for 8,000 formerly well paid professionals would cost $18,720,000.00 to the Texas and Federal Unemployment system(s).

 

New York-Northern New Jersey-Long Island, NY-NJ-PA Metropolitan Statistical Area

The New York MSA has the largest S&E Labor Force at 447,600

image

The Foreign born S&E share of the Labor Force only grew by 1% in the five years covered. The 6.5% Unemployment rate is rather high for a primarily college educated workforce.

 

image

In the Chart above, we see elasticity of 30,000 Native born professionals in the New York MSA. The increase in the employment of 30,000 for the Native born only decreased the Unemployment level by about 2,500 in 2006 (this is likely due to the hiring of new college graduates). 

It is interesting to note that the increase in Unemployment from 2008 to 20009, coincides with the decrease in the Employment level of the foreign born.  The drastic drop in employment of the Native born does not show a corresponding rise in Unemployment levels.

From 2009 forward, the 30,000 the newly hired Native born professionals have been dismissed.

San Jose-Sunnyvale-Santa Clara, CA Metropolitan Statistical Area

 

image

In the Silicon Valley area, we see a 3% increase in the already very high Foreign born S&E Labor force.   Additionally, the 7.6%  Unemployment rate is disturbing for the center of the universe for all things technical.

  image

There does not appear to be the wildcat layoffs of Native born professionals, in the San Jose MSA.

The chart above seems to indicate that for every 15,000 Foreign born professionals that are hired, 3,000 jobs for Native born professionals are created.  The H-1B propaganda machine seems to have their ( “Each H-1B creates Five jobs”) statistics backwards. 

 

Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue, WA Metropolitan Statistical Area

This report wouldn’t be complete if the Microsoft Metropolitan Area wasn’t included.

image

 

The first thing I notice above is that the Foreign born S&E Labor force levels increased by 6.1%

 

image

In the above Chart, we clearly see the (Native born) labor elasticity of about 18,000 S&E professionals. It also appears that the 2008 recession only affected Native born professionals. 

The  (2005 to 2009) addition of Native born professionals only flattened the Unemployment level, but did not show a decline.  There is however, a rise in Unemployment levels that corresponds with the increasing level of Foreign born professionals.

There is also an odd two year offset in this chart between the commencement of Native born professionals (2005) and the hiring commencement of Foreign born professionals (2007).  It would appear that the Seattle MSA is benefiting from the stricter adjudication of H-1B visas over these past years.

In closing, the data suggests that there is more than adequate labor elasticity in the Native Born S&E Labor Force.  Knowingly or not, High Skill immigration allows US Employers to socialize employment costs onto the Unemployment Insurance System.

I would suggest that we modernize our State Unemployment Claims systems to require the inclusion of occupational titles, so that the need for business-related immigration can be electronically verified regionally.  Additionally, the Department of Labor’s occupational classification for H-1B visa should be updated to the modern NAICS-SOC, rather than the Dictionary of Occupational Titles (DOT), which was last updated in 1991.

 

Source Data:

Census, Current Population Survey (CPS)

Downloaded from: Population Reference Bureau, March 4, 2012

Source: Population Reference Bureau analysis of the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey (ACS) internal microdata files.

Definition: Scientists and engineers include people in computer science, engineering, architecture, life science, physical science, and social science occupations.

Notes: Data are subject to both sampling and nonsampling error. A hyphen (-) indicates data are not available

Thursday, January 5, 2012

Radical Conservative Immigration Policy

“Each 100 H-1B Initial Employment Approvals are associated with 90 job losses for ‘Natives’ from 2001 to 2010.”

We have yet another “study” of immigrants in the United States workforce, this one associates different classes of immigrants with employment creation for “natives”.  The study is short on definitions, does not include a list of assumptions and does not include data, but heck let’s just take the author’s word that all is correct and good.

Today’s Featured Study:

“IMMIGRATION AND AMERICAN JOBS”

AMERICAN ENTERPRISE INSTITUTE FOR PUBLIC POLICY RESEARCH AND THE PARTNERSHIP FOR A NEW AMERICAN ECONOMY

Written by:  Madeline Zavodny
http://www.renewoureconomy.org/aeireport

 

While the country teeters on the edge of a double dip recession, let’s plug-in some numbers into the formulas that the “conservative” think tanks are promoting as an employment growth solution.  Our goal here is to reduce the Current U-6 Underutilization Rate by 33%, thus creating 8 million jobs for “natives” by allowing more immigration as Ms. Zavodny suggests.

I present “What if” scenario CASE 1: and CASE 2: for creating 8 million jobs for “Natives” as per Zavodny’s policy recommendation.

CASE 1:

Zavodny: “Every additional 100 foreign-born workers with an advanced
degree created an additional 44 jobs for US natives.”

image

In the table above we see that adding 18 million new persons with advanced degrees to the labor force “might” bring the Unemployment rate down to levels that are considered “full employment”. 

On the other hand, if Zavodny’s conclusions are wrong and the economy does not create 26 million new jobs as a result of adding these immigrants, the Headline Unemployment rate (U-3) would climb to 18.3% and the United States would be stuck with 18 million more people to house, clothe and feed.  This would be some pretty high-stakes policy poker.

 

CASE 2:

Zavodny: “Every additional 100 foreign-born workers who earned
an advanced degree in the US and then worked in
STEM fields created an additional 262 jobs for US natives.”

image

The chart above is a bit more conservative with 2.62 native jobs created for every immigrant with a US advanced STEM degree.  In this case we only need to bring in about 3 million immigrants and dedicate 100% of the science curriculum to STEM disciplines – AND -- dedicate all of the NCES advanced degree programs to immigrants for the next 10 years. 

image

The STEM occupations employ about 7.6 million persons, but only 1.8 million in the STEM occupations have an advanced degree.  Another 3.3 million STEM workers have bachelor’s degrees and about 2.4 million have some college, an associate degree or less. Adding 3 million immigrants to a population which is now only 1.8 million -- might tend to affect wages a little bit.

If the Zavodny Formula for STEM workers were to fail and these new immigrants were to engage in an employment bidding war to remain employed in the United States, the likely result would be another spate of housing foreclosures.   The Census homeownership rate is currently 66.3%, STEM is a well paying field, so failure of this Zavodny Formula could cause slightly more than 2.2 million additional housing foreclosures.  Fresh out of college immigrants would predominately enter the rental housing market.

CASE 3:

Zavodny: “The estimates show that a 10 percent increase in
H-1B workers, relative to total employment, is associated
with a 0.11 percent increase in the native
employment rate. During the sample period of
2001–2010, this translates into each additional 100
approved H-1B workers being associated with an
additional 183 jobs among US natives.”

 

Okay, we get down to the meat of the “citizenship provisional” visa, the H-1B.  This is the temporary worker program that encourages foreign nationals to squander their youth chasing the dream of US citizenship; it is reasonable to conclude that citizenship will not be awarded until the worker has completed 10 to 15 years of continuous employment. Why? Because corporate lobbyists have favored temporary immigration over the Employment Based Preference entrance visa with a 5 year Lawful Permanent Residence requirement prior to naturalization.

I have no idea how to decipher Zavodny’s statement, “…a 10 percent increase in H-1B workers, relative to total employment…”, is the 10 percent increase a variable in a regression formula? Or, an increase in the actual data? Is the 10 percent H-1B increase offset by a year, or instantaneous?

Displayed below is the actual H-1B Initial Employment Approvals aligned with the Total Loss/Gain in BLS employment levels for the years 2001-2010.

image

I can’t see how Zavodny arrives at a 100 to 183 jobs for “Natives” ratio for the same period, when considering the numbers in the above table, I guess I’ll never understand the new math(s).

Rebuttal Data:

Census Homeownership Data:

http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/housing/hvs/qtr311/graph311.html

Educational Data:

WebCASPAR Integrated Science and Engineering Resources Data System

https://webcaspar.nsf.gov/index.jsp?subHeader=WebCASPARHome

H-1B Initial Employment Approvals:

“USCIS: Characteristics of H-1B Specialty Occupation Workers”

Fiscal Years 2001 through 2009

Employment Level Loss/Gain Data:

Labor Force Statistics from the Current Population Survey

Series Id: LNU00000000

Not Seasonally Adjusted

Series title: (Unadj) Population Level

Labor force status: Civilian noninstitutional population

Type of data: Number in thousands Age: 16 years and over

Data extracted on: January 1, 2012 (3:55:39 PM)

http://www.bls.gov/data/

STEM Employment and Educational Statistics

U.S. Department of Commerce
Economics and Statistics Administration

“STEM: Good Jobs Now and for the Future”

By David Langdon, George McKittrick, David Beede, Beethika Khan, and Mark Doms,
Office of the Chief Economist

Thursday, October 27, 2011

The Boeing 787 Dreamliner and the Purple Squirrel

In its effort to create the 787 commercial airplane, it appears that Boeing has also participated in the search for the elusive Purple Squirrel. The Boeing 787 has been an offshore outsourcing failure, a costly lesson learned by the largest exporter in United States. The bird (787) does fly, but with a 3-year overdue delivery date, Boeing has had to provide price discounts of 25% on some of the earliest pre-purchases.

Project managers often use the “Faster, Cheaper, Better” mantra to sell a project based upon optimistic timelines or budgets, most engineers will respond with “pick two” and more often than not the engineers are correct.

 The 787 Project: 

 Faster: Failed, 2008 projected date, time wasted creating outsourcer supply-chain difficulties. Technology issues also arose during the project – which should have been expected in cases where emerging technologies are employed.

Cheaper: I’m sure that Boeing’s version of cheaper didn’t include cost and time overruns and deep discounts granted to companies who placed pre-production purchase orders. See “Better” Better: Commercial airplanes are the ultimate durable-good, many are flown for decades and safety should be the ultimate concern; “Better” should have the highest priority. The “Cheaper” aspect of the project could still be salvaged, if purchasers find that the 787 is a durable (and safe) aircraft. Boeing may experience a lager market share, offsetting production and engineering cost overruns, dependent upon durability and fuel savings.

The Boeing 737 Wikipedia entry says that there are still thousand of 737s in the air at all times of the day. The point is, that Boeing went cheap on the “Faster” aspect of the project and paid the price. Attempting to save time and money on project engineering, Boeing assumed that outsourcing would somehow mitigate a failure to maintain “institutional knowledge” and/or a resistance to train new staff.

"You have to realize that we hadn’t done a major development program at Boeing since the triple seven, you know that was 20 years ago, we had lost a lot of the institutional knowledge, we have got a lot of institutional knowledge now, we have trained 12,000 to 13,000 Engineers on how to do it right." 

Video transcript excerpt: Jim Albaugh, CEO Boeing Commercial Airplanes 

Some people in management tend to believe that Purple Squirrels do exist. Somehow, somewhere there is a highly skilled employee candidate who is pre-configured with the exact skills and knowledge needed to staff a project that may even involve emerging technology. Once the list of United States candidates have been exhausted/discounted, management lobbies the government for more temporary employment visas because they want to look at more squirrels to see if they can find a purple one.

 The Wall Street Journal has actually printed an article that doesn’t blindly support the “shortage” of Purple Squirrels in Science, Technology, Engineering and Math candidates. During the worst employment market since the Great Depression, there are lots of squirrels – again many employers are still not interested in squirrels that are not purple.

Dr. Peter Cappelli, Director of Wharton's Center for Human Resources, in The Wall Street Journal: With an abundance of workers to choose from, employers are demanding more of job candidates than ever before. They want prospective workers to be able to fill a role right away, without any training or ramp-up time. In other words, to get a job, you have to have that job already. It's a Catch-22 situation for workers—and it's hurting companies and the economy. To get America's job engine revving again, companies need to stop pinning so much of the blame on our nation's education system. They need to drop the idea of finding perfect candidates and look for people who could do the job with a bit of training and practice.

Dr. Peter Cappelli, “Why Companies Aren’t Getting the Employees They Need” The Wall Street Journal, 10/24/2011

Dr. Cappelli did a follow up article due to the avalanche of reader response. Most of the emails I received were in support of my argument, especially from readers struggling to get a job themselves. No surprise there. But a remarkable number of those who wrote were in positions where they were hiring, including recruiters. They reported that their organizations had shortages of employees because they would not train or invest in new hires. My favorite email came from somebody in a company that had 25,000 applicants for an engineering position and the staffing people said none of them were qualified. Could that really be possible?

Once the employer and recruiter have determined that there is no such thing as a Purple Squirrel, they tend to complain that there are not enough temporary work visas squirrels. A suspicious mind may conclude that employers might want to have additional leverage over any worker that they need to train -- a work-visa might just fit the definition of leverage for squirrels who don't happen to be purple. Fortunately, the CEO of Boeing Commercial Airplanes (Jim Albaugh) has come to the realization that regular squirrels can be trained just like purple ones.

Mr. Albaugh also appears to have come to the realization that squirrels tend to work better together in-groups where the output can be controlled.

“You have to realize that we hadn’t done a major development program at Boeing since the triple seven, you know that was 20 years ago, we had lost a lot of the institutional knowledge; we have got a lot of institutional knowledge now, we have trained 12,000 to 13,000 Engineers on how to do it right.”
“I think we over-stretched this time with some of our technologies and I think that we didn’t completely think through the supply-chain that we put in place. I think we’ve been able to address the technology issues and we’ve pulled some work back from the supply chain, we’re doing it internally…” “Obviously, whenever you have an issue you want to learn from it. We are doing a variant of the 787-8 and the 787-9 we’re doing more of the work inside the company now, we want to make sure we don’t lose control like we did on the 787-8” 
CNNMoney Video transcript excerpts, Jim Albaugh, CEO Boeing Commercial Airplanes 


Video Courtesy of CNNMoney “Boeing's game changer finishes first flight” By Chris Isidore @CNNMoney October 26, 2011: 1:43 PM ET http://money.cnn.com/2011/10/25/news/companies/boeing_787_dreamliner/

 See also: W.T.O. Ruling on Airbus Subsidies Upheld on Appeal By NICOLA CLARK Published: May 18, 2011 http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/19/business/global/19wto.html?pagewanted=all Special Thanks to Dr. Peter Cappelli for his WSJ article

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

The WTO GATS and H-1B Pundits Pandering in The Media

I've noticed an interesting phenomena lately, studies on skilled immigrants get quoted in other later studies until the the quoted material has largely a different meaning. 

Paraphrasing:  25% of new startup corporations had immigrant founders

The studies I've read on the immigrant founders appear to come from the same data, but the part left out is that the immigrant founder is generally one of five founders. From one of the early studies, I ran the numbers and found that when the four American founders are factored in, the likelihood of two immigrant founders in the same company would be low and that the performance of the immigrant founder reflected the immigrant population at large.

Some media and industry pundits have been quoting an NFAP study (Table 1) to infer that the H-1B visa is only .06% of the labor force and, from the omission of a footnote, infer that the numerical cap on H-1B visa has reverted to the 1998 levels of 65,000.  The 65,000 H-1B cap inference is far from the truth in the matter.


The “American Competiveness in the Twenty-First Century Act,” (AC21) created special carve-outs with unlimited cap exemptions for certain Nonprofit, University and Government entities. Additionally, the “H-1B Reform Act of 2004,” added 20,000 visas to the H-1B for postgraduates of U.S. Universities. Without the AC21exemptions and additional 20,000 visas for postgraduates, a 1998 temporary increase in H-1B numerical cap would have expired in 2002 subsequently, an average 43,441 per year (since 2005) nonimmigrants would have competed for visas within the numerical cap of 65,000.

Average Yearly H-1B Approvals since the H-1B Reform Act of 2004 (2005 – 2009)

Avg. Initial Employment Approvals (2005 – 2009) = 108,441
Avg. Continuing Employment Approvals (2005 – 2009) = 153,504

Note: AC21 also provided additional single year extensions for PERM dual-intent applicants; this is why H-1B continuing employment approvals consistently exceed initial employment approvals since FY 2003 – effectively extending the H-1B and L-1 temporary visas from 5 to 7 years, into the decade timeframe.

Very creative taglines tend to be sensationalized in the zeal to increase the foreign worker quotas during this recession, from the NFAP study, “With the annual flow of H-1Bs representing only 0.06 percent of the U.S. labor force in 2009, arguments that H-1B professionals overwhelm the American workforce are not supported by logic or the facts.” Beyond the data-banding use of only a portion of the H-1B caps, quoting the statement misleads the casual reader, ignoring the fact that the H-1B is a six year duration visa and implying that all occupations in the Labor force are open to the H-1B program. Looking at the H-1B in terms of the entire Labor Force is quite slanted. The Computer related occupations data displays the misuse and subsequent cause for resentment of the H-1B program.

(IT) Computer Related Occupations:

Growth in Employment (IT) Levels (2005-09) = 382,640 (12% emp. growth)
H-1B initial (IT) employment approvals (2005-09) = 258,870 (67.7% of emp. growth)
(Source: USCIS, H-1B Characteristics Series)

(IT) Assoc. thru PhD Degrees Conferred (2004-08) = 529,798 (138% of emp. growth)
(Excludes temporary residents -- citizen and perm resident degrees conferred only)
(Source: NCES, IPEDS Completions Survey)

From the growth statistics listed above, we can see that the U.S. is being far too generous with the employment opportunities granted to citizens of Least Developed Countries (LDC). It is not by accident that the highest percentages of H-1B and L-1 nonimmigrants come from LDC regions, LDC have preferential negotiating privileges in the GATS arena. Global Trade in Services, as a form of Direct Foreign Aid may be a noble cause, but the U.S. cannot afford to be so generous as to bankrupt its citizens.

The next section explores areas where U.S. immigration policy exceeds negotiated trade commitments.

General Agreement in Trade and Services (GATS)

H-1B (Fashion Models and Specialty Occupations) and L-1 (Intra-corporate) visas are specifically named and committed in General Agreement in Trade and Services (GATS) trade commitments. Eliminating the H-1B and L-1 visa programs would be next to impossible. However, under GATS, the terms of these visas are considerably different from the terms in U.S. law.

 Under GATS: there are no dual-intent citizenship provisions for H-1B, or L-1 visa, this is considered “poaching” and is detrimental to Least Developed Countries

 Under (AC21) U.S. Law: The H-1B and L-1 visa durations may be extended into the decade timeframe: ”The Attorney General shall extend the stay of an alien who qualifies for an exemption under subsection (a) in one-year increments until such time as a final decision is made on the alien’s lawful permanent residence.”

 Under GATS, the H-1B is a three year visa with a 65,000 per year worldwide limitation.

 There is no GATS requirement or provision for extension of the H-1B beyond 3 years.

 Under GATS, the L-1 visa is allowed a single 2 year extension; under U.S. law the L-1A can be granted two 2 year extensions after the initial 3 year period.

 Under GATS, the no-layoff provisions are 6 month preceding and 90 days following a nonimmigrant employment application. Under US Law the layoff restrictions are 90 days – 90 days, but the 90/90 rule is only applicable for H-1B Dependent Employers.

Over a six year period (2004-09), Americans assumed about 101,000 of 600,000 new jobs in Computer related occupations (IT). for a matching period (2003-08) about 110,000 postgraduate IT degrees were awarded to American citizens and permanent residents.  This indicates that only Americans with postgraduate degrees are being hired and that the minimum educational level for H-1B in IT occupations should be raised to the postgraduate level.  Moreover, 2006 NSF data indicates that 31,000 of the 57,000 new H-1B awarded in IT had undergraduate degrees.

http://immigration-weaver.blogspot.com/2010/06/h-1b-visa-impact-on-computer-related.html


US GATS Commitment

d) the employer has not laid off or otherwise displaced workers in the subject occupation in the previous six months and will not lay off or displace any US worker during the 90-day period following the filing of an application or the 90-day periods preceding and following the filing of any visa petition supported by the application; e) the employer has taken and is taking timely and significant steps to recruit and retain sufficient US workers in the specialty occupation; and f) notice is given at the time of application by the employer to employees or their representatives at the place of employment.

US 20 CFR 655.738

(c) Direct displacement. An H-1B-dependent or willful-violator employer (as described in §655.736) is prohibited from displacing a U.S. worker in its own workforce (i.e., a U.S. worker "employed by the employer") within the period beginning 90 days before and ending 90 days after the filing date of an H-1B petition supported by an LCA described in §655.736(g). The following standards and guidance apply under the direct displacement prohibition:

I'm just saying, a lot of times what's written and what the truth is are sometimes a bit misleading.

Source:

N A T I O N A L F O U N D A T I O N F O R A M E R I C A N P O L I C Y

H - 1 B V I S A S B Y T H E N U M B E R S: 2 0 1 0 A N D B E Y O N D

http://www.nfap.com/pdf/1003h1b.pdf

GATS Conditions to Achieve Developing Country Objectives
http://www.southcentre.org/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=109&Itemid=&lang=en


GATS -- THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA - INITIAL OFFER

http://www.uscsi.org/pdf/USinitialoffer.pdf


GATS DATABASE of Commitments (Commitments have changed since initial offer)
http://tsdb.wto.org/default.aspx


TITLE I— AMERICAN COMPETITIVENESS IN THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY (AC21)
http://www.gpoaccess.gov/serialset/cdocuments/sd106-30/pdf/pl106-313.pdf

‘‘(5) The numerical limitations contained in paragraph (1)(A) shall not apply to any nonimmigrant alien issued a visa or otherwise provided status under section 101(a)(15)(H)(i)(b) who is employed (or has received an offer of employment) at— ‘‘(A) an institution of higher education (as defined in section 101(a) of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1001(a))), or a related or affiliated nonprofit entity; or ‘‘(B) a nonprofit research organization or a governmental research organization.

H-1B Dependent Employer
http://www.dol.gov/dol/allcfr/title_20/Part_655/20CFR655.736.htm

Displacement of US worker obligation for H-1B dependent and Willful Violators
http://www.dol.gov/dol/allcfr/title_20/Part_655/20CFR655.738.htm

Allocation of Additional H-1B Visas Created by the H-1B Visa Reform Act of 2004 [70 FR 23775] [FR 19-05]
http://www.uscis.gov/ilink/docView/FR/HTML/FR/0-0-0-1/0-0-0-102229/0-0-0-106136/0-0-0-106262.html

Immigrant Intent and the Dual Intent Doctrine
Written by Henry J. Chang
http://www.americanlaw.com/dintent.html


Appendix 1
Current subsection of GATS US Commitments concerning L-1 and H-1B visa

All Sectors: Temporary Entry And Stay of Natural Persons1

4) Unbound, except for measures concerning temporary entry and stay of nationals of another member who fall into the categories listed below:

4) Unbound

Services Salespersons - persons not based in the territory of the United States and receiving no remuneration from a source located within the United States, who are engaged in activities related to representing a services supplier for the purpose of negotiating for the sale of the services of that supplier where: a) such sales are not directly made to the general public and b) the salesperson is not engaged in supplying the service. Entry for persons named in this section is limited to a ninety-day period.


Intra-corporate Transferees - managers, executives and specialists, as defined below, who are employees of firms that provide services within the United States through a branch, subsidiary, or affiliate established in the United States and who have been in the prior employ of their firm outside the United States for a period of not less than one year immediately preceding the date of their application for admission and who are one of the following:

a) Managers - persons within an organization who primarily direct the organization, or a department or sub-division of the organization, supervise and control the work of other supervisory, professional or managerial employees, have the authority to hire and fire or recommend hiring, firing, or other personnel actions (such as promotion or leave authorization), and exercise discretionary authority over day-to-day operations. Does not include first-line supervisors, unless the employees supervised are professionals, nor does it include employees who primarily perform tasks necessary for the provision of the service.

b) Executives - persons within the organization who primarily direct the management of the organization, establish the goals and policies of the organization, exercise wide latitude in decision-making, and receive only general supervision or direction from higher-level executives, the board of directors, or stockholders of the business. Executives would not directly perform tasks related to the actual provision of a service or services of the organization.

c) Specialists - persons within an organization who possess knowledge at an advanced level of continued expertise and who possess proprietary knowledge of the organization's services, research equipment, techniques, or management. (Specialists may include, but are not limited to, members of licenced professions.)

Entry for persons named in this section is limited to a three-year period that may be extended for up to two additional years for a total term not to exceed five years.

Personnel Engaged in Establishment - A person who has been employed in the immediately preceding year by an entity described in Section II, receiving remuneration from that source, who occupies a managerial or executive position with that entity and is entering the territory of the United States for the purpose of establishing an entity described in Section II that will support employment of persons named in paragraphs a), b), and c) therein. The subject persons shall present proof of acquisition of physical premises for the entity that shall commence its business operations within one year of the date of entry of that person.

Fashion Models and Specialty Occupations - Up to 65,000 persons annually on a world-wide basis in occupations as set out in 8 USC. ' 1101 (a) (15) (H) (i) (b), consisting of (i) fashion models who are of distinguished merit and ability; and (ii) persons engaged in a specialty occupation, requiring (a) theoretical and practical application of a body of highly specialized knowledge; and (b) attainment of a bachelor's or higher degree in the specialty (or its equivalent) as a minimum for entry into the occupation in the United States. Persons seeking admission under (ii) above shall possess the following qualifications: (a) full licensure in a US state to practice in the occupation, if such licensure is required to practice in the occupation in that state; and (b) completion of the required degree, or experience in the specialty equivalent to the completion of the required degree and recognition of expertise in the specialty through progressively responsible positions relating to the specialty. Entry for persons named in this section is limited to three years.

Specialty occupation aliens and their employers must be in compliance with all labour condition application requirements that are attested to by the established employer. These requirements are: a) wages paid to the person are the greater of: 1) the actual wage paid by the employer to individuals in that place of employment with similar qualifications and experience, or 2) the prevailing wage for that occupational classification in the area of employment; b) conditions of work are such that they will not adversely affect working conditions for those similarly employed; c) there is no strike or lockout in the course of a labour/management dispute in progress at the place of employment affecting the subject occupation; labour/management dispute in progress at the place of employment;

d) the employer has not laid off or otherwise displaced workers in the subject occupation in the previous six months and will not lay off or displace any US worker during the 90-day period following the filing of an application or the 90-day periods preceding and following the filing of any visa petition supported by the application; e) the employer has taken and is taking timely and significant steps to recruit and retain sufficient US workers in the specialty occupation; and f) notice is given at the time of application by the employer to employees or their representatives at the place of employment.

Tuesday, June 22, 2010

H-1B visa: Impact on Computer-related Occupations 2009

From 2004-09, IT employment grew by 602,000. New H-1B initial approvals in Computer related occupations was 315,249 or 52.4% of employment growth, similar temporary foreign worker categories likely raised the temporary foreign worker percentage to above 80% of employment growth. Over a similar period (2003-08), there was an abundance of new IT workers, as U.S. Citizen/Permanent Resident degree production exceeded demand at over 757,000 degrees conferred.


From 2004-09, only 2,360 jobs were created in "Computer and information scientists, research," the only category that requires a postgraduate degree (per CA PostSecondary Education Committee). Contrary to the graph above, if we exclude all new A.S. degrees, and assume all Tech support workers must have a B.S. degree, the educational system still performed adequately when foreign students are counted. (Earlier study by specialty also shows no IT talent shortage)

U.S. Computer related degrees conferred (B.S., M.S., Prof. and PhD 2003 - 08)
U.S. Citizen and Permanent Residents = 505,042
Temporary Residents = 95.898
Total Degrees, Bachelors and above = 600,940
Computer related employment growth (2004-09) = 602,180 (100%)
H-1B visa, new approvals = 315,249 (52.4%)
L-1 visas issued (2005-09) est. 50% of incoming are IT = 185,689 (30.8%)
H-1B and L-1 employment growth total = 501,118 (83.2%)
Between 315,000 and 501,000 new IT jobs were assumed by H-1B and L-1 temporary workers. Excluding the degrees conferred to Temporary Residents, the unemployment rate for this segment of the workforce would be between 26.6% and/or 67.1% respectively.  Speaking of unemployment, a modest 3% unemployment rate for the occupation provides another 96,000 persons in the ready workforce.



Referring to the Graph above:

H-1B and L-1 must have an employment offer to enter the U.S. and must remain employed H-1B and L-1 est. increases amounted to 80% of employment growth from 2004-09 Hiring counts of Citizen and PermRes are nearly identical to U.S. postgraduate degrees conferred Postgrad degree now preferred for Citizens/PermRes while undergrad degree for H-1 B, L-1 Undergraduate Citizen and PermRes are displaced by H-1B, L-1 or "crowd out" older Professionals The Computer related occupations are oversubscribed with foreign undergraduate level professionals.

The Question:
How did we arrive at the point where 52% of all new IT hires are H-1B and historically about 50% of all H-1B are in IT occupations?

The, "U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Office of Occupational Statistics and Employment Projections," predicted that Computer Specialist occupational levels would reach 4.2 million, an increase of 1.9 million (82%) by 2010.  The predicted "dire shortages" of Computer specialists did not occur because employment levels only reached 3.2 million in 2009.

Employers claim that they need this "slack" in the employment market and need access to the brightest in the world -- for the years in question, employment levels that require a postgraduate degree only grew by 2,360.

Recommendation:

The 2/3 employment retention rule:
Business immigration is privilege, not a right, the most damaging aspect of the H-1B program is that it is unrestricted during recessions and unrestricted during the early stages of recovery.  When water is splashed from a puddle, it is replaced with other water; in the case of unstoppable flow foreign labor, unemployment becomes permanent when an oversupply of  labor exists during and after recession..

Metering the intake of  foreign workers is extremely important when the business cycle is declining.  Measured by occupations, the temporary foreign worker educational requirements should be adjusted upward when the count of new temporary workers exceeds 1/3 of employment growth statistic (more below).   While keeping the door open for the brightest and best postgraduates (58% in 2009) and allowing the business cycle to run its course, the intake of undergraduate foreign professionals would be halted during recession and through early stages of recovery.

Three types of professionals are involved, but two of these professionals are the same person in a different time period: the U.S. professional, the temporary professional (H-1B), the dual-intent professional. Both the citizen and the dual-intent professional are interested in retaining permanent U.S. employment, the temporary professional is presumed to be mobile. From this perspective, the number of temporary foreign professionals should not exceed 1/3 of the long term employment growth statistic because there is already another, more seasoned, temporary professional who may choose to become a citizen.

.In an oversubscribed occupation such as IT, temporary layoffs in these permanent positions are often filled with new foreign workers instead of the separated worker.  In raising visa educational requirements when a 1/3 oversubscription occurs, temporary visa are still available to the industry while population ratio recovers. In a recovering business cycle, unemployed and new student professional are favored due to visa restrictions. As the business cycle peaks, the restrictions on visa educational requirements are reduced.

The employment growth statistic would cover a period equal to the maturity of the temporary visa.  The 2/3 employment retention rule protects citizens, permanent residents and persons adjusting status from permanent employment separation during recession.  The 2/3 employment retention rule would discourage offshore outsourcing because a reduction in staff causes an immigration restriction within the occupation for the following year(s). The rule would allow separated workers and new college graduates a short term "grace" period while the economy is suffering and recovering from recession. Finally, the 2/3 employment reservation rule would help ensure that employment based immigration policy leans toward employment retention of current and future citizens.

This paper examines a six year period of:
Occupational Employment Growth
Employment based visas granted or employment approvals in the H-1B and L-1 categories
U.S. college degrees conferred in Computer related occupations.



H-1B Visa Impact on Computer Related Occupations 2009

We finally have the USCIS, "Characteristics of Specialty Occupation Workers (H-1B):" reports. These H-1B reports are important because they publish the numbers of visas approved and the occupations of the new H-1B non-immigrant worker(s). Lou Dobbs started reporting about the excessive amount of H-1B workers affecting Computer related occupations in about 2006-07. The 2006-07 H-1B Characteristics reports, mandated by Congress, went unpublished for the remainder of the Bush Presidency.

Occupational Employment Data:
The Office of Employment Statistics (OES) has released its May 2009, estimates of the occupational employment and current wages. To determine the impact of these non-immigrant visa programs in the occupation, the first step is to find the employment growth in Computer related occupations.


Six year Growth in Computer related occupations 2004 - 2009
 Entry Level Education Prereq (STEPS)

Computer and information scientists, research = 2,360 PhD
Computer programmers = ( -35,340) BS
Computer software engineers, applications = 84,920 BS
Computer software engineers, systems software = 92,680 BS
Computer support specialists = 60,040 AS
Computer systems analysts = 27,000 BS
Database administrators = 10,540 BS
Network and computer systems administrators = 94,280 BS
Network systems and data communications analysts = 69,810 BS
Computer specialists, all other = 195,890 AS

Occupational Employment growth = 602,180

Even though the Computer related occupations lost (-1,120) jobs in 2009, employment growth of 602,180 jobs is a lot better than some of the other periods I've looked at. These were pretty good employment growth years, between recessions and notably , the Tech sector started hiring again in 2004.

I've sampled a six year growth period, because six years is the duration of the standard H-1B temporary foreign worker visa, with a three year initial and a three year continuing employment period.

Temporary Foreign Worker Data:
By the numbers, virtually all H-1B visas are renewed, or extended, counts of continuing employment approvals consistently exceed initial employment approvals. Excess visa counts in continuing approvals are due to a combination of continuing 3 year employment approvals and greencard (AC21) extensions, but these are still H-1B workers just the same.  The H-1B count is this report are limited to initial employment approvals in Computer related occupations.

An H-1B non-immigrant worker cannot enter the U.S. without employment, so we know that a certain amount of occupational growth is/was reserved for H-1B initial employment.


Occupational Employment growth = 602,180
H-1B initial emp. approvals 2004 - 09 = 315,429 (52%)

Occupational Subtotal = 286,751


The H-1B is not the only non-immigrant visa that adversely affects Computer related occupations. The "Intra-company" L-1 visa, is also a three year visa, but differs with a single two year extension for workers and can be extended twice for managers. The Office of Inspector General (OIG) has studied the L-1 visa and poses the question in a section heading, "Is the L-1, The Computer visa?" ...quoted from the same section... "From 1999 to 2004, nine of the ten firms that petitioned for the most L-1 workers were computer and IT related outsourcing service firms that specialize in labor from India."

Like the H-1B visa, the L-1 visa is also "portable" under AC21 (greencard eligible) immigration law. In this estimate I will use 50% of the L-1 (instead of the OIG estimate of 90%) and limit the duration to a single extension of 5 years total. Computer related occupations within the H-1b program is generally 50%, the L-1 should be at least half Computer related considering the OIG documentation.


Occupational Subtotal = 286,751
50% of L-1 visas issued 2005 - 09 = 185,689

Subtotal (America's share 16.78% of occupational growth) = 101,063

Consequently, Americans are resigned to accept that 83% of its Computer related employment growth is reserved for H-1b and L-1 non-immigrants. Even with the current state of the economy, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce (and others) lobbies for more high-skill non-immigrant visas.

Occupational Characteristics of IT related H-1B
Of the 56,000 IT related H-1B visas granted in 2006, 55% of these new H-1B holders were undergraduates (31,000).  Sixty six percent of all (47,300 total) undergraduate H-1B initial approvals in 2006 were in Computer related (IT) occupations.  All other occupations combined only received 16,300 H-1B undergraduates.
In 2006, 44% of those receiving new H-1B visas in computer-related occupations had master’s degrees, and a little more than 1% had doctoral degrees. Over two-thirds of the slightly more than 110,000 recipients of H-1B visas in 2006 are in S&T occupations Education Levels. .


In FY 2006, 57% of [all] new H-1B visa recipients had advanced degrees, including 41% with master’s degrees, 5% with professional degree, and 11% with doctorates. http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/seind08/c3/c3s4.htm
From 2004-09, only 2,360 jobs were created in "Computer and information scientists, research," the only category that requires a postgraduate degree (per CA PostSecondary Education Committee).


U.S. Educational Data:
The latest (NCES) educational data is for 2008,. I've downloaded Computer related "Degrees Conferred" data for the six year period (2003 - 2008),for comparison with the {six year} Computer related occupational growth data.



Computer related occupations
Degrees conferred 2003 - 2008

U.S. Citizens and Permanent Residents

Professional and PHD = 3,807
Masters = 106,614
Bachelors = 394,621
Associate = 252,720

Total Degrees Conferred = 757,762

Referring to the Graph above:

H-1B and L-1 must have an employment offer to enter the U.S. and must remain employed Hiring counts of Citizen and PermRes are nearly identical to postgraduate degrees conferred Undergraduate Citizen and PermRes are displaced in competition with H-1B, L-1 Employment requirements are postgraduate for Citizens/PermRes and undergrad for H-1 B, L-1.

Finally, there is a little more competition in the system -- foreign students.


Computer related occupations
Degrees conferred 2003 - 2008

Temporary Residents

Professional and PHD = 5,158
Masters = 60,290
Bachelors = 30,450
Associate = 5,114

Total = 101,012

About Educational Data:
Many foreign students will enter the H-1B or OPT programs.

Counts of degrees conferred could contain duplicates -- a B.S. holder might also have earned an A.S. during the sample period.

Some persons in the degrees conferred data may already be employed in IT, however 1 and 2 year certificate data are not included here.

Observations:
IT employers claim they need this much slack in the labor force and more H-1B is not responsive to the business cycle

The prerequisite for employment in IT has been raised to postgraduate degree for citizens/PermRes

There is an abundance of both H-1B and citizen/PermRes undergraduates

The long term plans for new H-1B are undeclared/uncertain

Employment retention must be a goal to accommodate citizens and new citizens

Conclusion:

The 2/3 employment retention rule:
Business immigration is privilege, not a right, the most damaging aspect of the H-1B program is that it is unrestricted during recessions and unrestricted during the early stages of recovery.When water is splashed from a puddle it is replaced with other water; thus, unemployment becomes permanent when an oversupply of labor exists during and after recession..

Metering the intake of foreign workers is extremely important when the business cycle is declining. Measured by occupations, the temporary foreign worker educational requirements should be adjusted upward when the count of new temporary workers exceeds 1/3 of employment growth statistic (more below). While keeping the door open for the brightest and best postgraduates (58% in 2009) and allowing the business cycle to run its course, the intake of undergraduate foreign professionals would be reduced during halted and through early stages of recovery.

Three types of professionals are involved, but two of these professionals are the same person in a different time period: the U.S. professional, the temporary professional (H-1B), the dual-intent professional. Both the citizen and the dual-intent professional are interested in retaining permanent U.S. employment, the temporary professional is presumed to be mobile. From this perspective, the number of temporary foreign professionals should not exceed 1/3 of the long term employment growth statistic because there is already another, more seasoned, temporary professional who may choose to become a citizen.

.In an oversubscribed occupation such as IT, temporary layoffs in these permanent positions are often filled with new foreign workers instead of the separated worker. In raising visa educational requirements when a 1/3 oversubscription occurs, temporary visa are still available to the industry while population ratio recovers. In a recovering business cycle, unemployed and new student professional are favored due to visa restrictions. As the business cycle peaks, the restrictions on visa educational requirements are reduced.

The employment growth statistic would cover a period equal to the maturity of the visa. The 2/3 employment retention rule protects citizens, permanent residents and persons adjusting status from permanent employment separation during recession. The 2/3 employment retention rule would discourage offshore outsourcing because a reduction in staff causes an immigration restriction within the occupation for the following year(s). The rule would allow separated workers and new college graduates a short term "grace" period while the economy is suffering and recovering from recession. Finally, the 2/3 employment reservation rule would help ensure that employment based immigration policy leans toward employment retention of current and future citizens.

See Also:
A Shortage Where None is Found
http://immigration-weaver.blogspot.com/2009/08/shortage-where-none-is-found.html

Data Sources:

U.S. Department of State
Classes of Nonimmigrants Issued Visas – FY1989-2009 Detail Table (Excel Spreadsheet)
Parent: http://www.travel.state.gov/visa/statistics/nivstats/nivstats_4582.html

U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
Reports
USCIS, "Characteristics of Specialty Occupation Workers (H-1B): 2009
USCIS, "Characteristics of Specialty Occupation Workers (H-1B): 2008
USCIS, "Characteristics of Specialty Occupation Workers (H-1B): 2007
USCIS, "Characteristics of Specialty Occupation Workers (H-1B): 2006
USCIS, "Characteristics of Specialty Occupation Workers (H-1B): 2005
USCIS, "Characteristics of Specialty Occupation Workers (H-1B): 2004


U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
Reports:
Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates

National Cross Industry Estimates
2003 - 2009


Department Homeland Security : Office of the Inspector General
Report:
Review of Vulnerabilities and Potential Abuses of the L-1 Visa Program
http://www.dhs.gov/xoig/assets/katovrsght/OIG_06-22_Jan06.pdf

California PostSecondary Education Committee
http://www.cpec.ca.gov/FiscalData/StepsDetail.asp?SOC=15

National Science Foundation

Data Source: IPEDS Completions Survey by Race
Analysis Variable: Degrees/Awards Conferred by Race (NCES population of institutions)
01.0106 Agricultural Business Technology
11.0101 Computer and Information Sciences, General
11.0103 Information Technology
11.0199 Computer Science, Other
11.0201 Computer Programming/Programmer, General
11.0202 Computer Programming Special Applications
11.0299 Computer Programming, Other
11.0301 Data Processing and Data Processing Technology/Technician
11.0401 Information Science/Studies
11.0501 Computer Systems Analysis/Analyst
11.0701 Computer Science
11.0801 Web Page, Digital/Multimedia and Information Resources Design
11.0802 Data Modeling/Warehousing and Database Administration
11.0803 Computer Graphics
11.0899 Computer Software and Media Applications, Other
11.0901 Computer Systems Networking and Telecommunications
11.1001 System Administration/Administrator
11.1002 System, Networking, and LAN/WAN Management/Manager
11.1003 Computer and Information Systems Security
11.1004 Web/Multimedia Management and Webmaster
11.1099 Computer/Information Technology Services Administration and Management, Other
11.9999 Computer and Information Sciences and Support Services, Other
14.0901 Computer Engineering, General
14.0902 Computer Hardware Engineering
14.0903 Computer Software Engineering
14.0999 Computer Engineering, Other
15.1201 Computer Engineering Technology/ Technician
15.1202 Computer Technology/Computer Systems Technology
15.1204 Computer Software Technology/Technician
15.1299 Computer Engineering Technologies/Technicians, Other
26.1103 Bioinformatics
26.1199 Biomathematics and Bioinformatics, Other
51.2706 Medical Informatics
52.0208 E-Commerce/Electronic Commerce
52.1201 Management Information Systems, General
52.1299 Management Information Systems and Services, Other